NYS Housing and Anti-Discrimination Notice Signature Premier Properties, Licensed Real Estate Broker, 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, NY 11787, office (631) 360-2800
at Signature Premier Properties

Lindenhurst, New York · Seller's guide

Selling a House in Lindenhurst, NY

Thinking of selling your Lindenhurst home? The same questions come up for nearly everyone: what could it sell for, which repairs are worth paying for, what will the sale cost you, and whose advice can you rely on?

We're Danielle Sandella and Kim Fontanez, The SisterListers at Signature Premier Properties, and we sell homes in Lindenhurst and all over Long Island. Kim has lived in Lindenhurst for 40 years, and one of us walks every house we list. Here's what we'd tell you if we were sitting on your couch.

Who would be walking through your house

Why Lindenhurst sellers call us.

Kim Fontanez

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, New York license 10401314934, licensed since 2018. Mobile: (631) 404-5882

Danielle Sandella

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, New York license 10401246493, licensed since 2012. CBR designation, and she works in English and American Sign Language. Mobile: (631) 513-9821

40 years in Lindenhurst

Kim's home for four decades, so Lindenhurst is a place she knows from living in it.

Signature Premier Properties

Our Licensed Real Estate Broker. 7 West Main Street, Smithtown, and serving Lindenhurst sellers. Office: (631) 360-2800

30 homes sold for their owners

That's 30 listing-side sales. Our sold page shows them all.

One of us walks every house

Danielle or Kim comes to your Lindenhurst home in person, before anyone talks about a number.

Title closings first

Before she sold houses, Danielle worked in title closings, on the deeds, liens and certificates that decide whether a sale can close.

25 years in mortgage and underwriting

Kim knows what a lender will approve, and which problems with a house a lender will turn down.

Latest monthly figures

What is happening in Lindenhurst right now.

$652,500Typical (median) price
101.7%Paid against asking
20Days on market, median
38Sold in October
319Sold in the past 12 months

Data courtesy of OneKey MLS as distributed by MLS GRID as of October 2026. Any one month rests on a few dozen closings at most, so a handful of houses can swing these figures. Read our latest Lindenhurst report.

How we read these numbers

Watch what buyers have been paying over asking. In May, Lindenhurst homes sold for 106.8 percent of their asking price. June and July ran near 103.6, August touched 104.7, September came in at 103.0, and October at 101.7. The extra has been shrinking for months.

The price itself has hardly moved. Month by month over the last year, the median stayed between about $600,000 and $683,000, and October's $652,500 sits comfortably inside that range. Buyers aren't paying less for these houses. They're just less willing to go far past the asking price to get one.

Speed has held up. Last October the typical home took 46 days, and this October it took 20. So the buyers are here and moving, and they have become choosier about how far they'll stretch. We'd price for October's 101.7, not May's 106.8, and then look hard at how your particular house compares.

Putting a number on it

What is your home really worth?

Anyone selling a home in Lindenhurst has already looked it up online, and that figure is fine as conversation fodder. It came from a program that has never heard your boiler kick on and has no idea your neighbor's addition went up the year after yours.

We work the other way around. One of us walks the house first, and then we sit down with you and go through what has actually closed nearby, including the sales that help your case and the ones that don't. Asking prices are wishes. A sold price is a fact, and even a fact needs some reading.

Your opening weeks carry the most weight. Everyone who has been watching your price range looks at a new listing right away. Priced well, those people come out and start to worry about each other. Priced too high, they pass, and a few weeks later the newcomers want to know what's the matter with the place. A reduction usually follows, often to less than an honest first number would have brought.

Be careful with anyone who comes in thousands above everybody else. A generous figure at the kitchen table costs nothing to say. It starts costing you about three weeks later. If you'd like a rough starting figure before we meet, our home value form will give you one.

What we compare when we look at closed sales

  • How recent it was. What Lindenhurst buyers pay moves through the year, so a spring sale needs some adjusting.
  • Size and style. A three-bedroom ranch and a four-bedroom colonial get shopped by different people at different prices.
  • Condition you can see and condition you can't. Updated rooms count, and so does the age of the roof, the heat and the electrical service.
  • The way the house lives. A bedroom on the main floor, a kitchen that opens up, or a bath you reach only through someone's room will push a value one way or the other.
  • The land and the road. Usable yard is worth more than sloped yard of the same size, and heavy traffic out front has a price.
  • The tax bill. People compare monthly payments, so a big tax difference acts like a difference in price.
  • The competition this weekend. Closed sales show what already happened. The homes for sale today are what your buyer will tour right before or after yours.

Should you start high and leave room to negotiate?

We understand the instinct, and it tends to work against you. Search filters run on price, so an inflated figure puts your house in front of shoppers who have nicer options at that level and hides it from those who would have been happy with it. Those people won't come in with a lower offer, because they'll never know your home exists.

Should you start low and let buyers fight?

Now and then a price set slightly beneath the market pulls in a crowd. It takes a month with real demand and a house people truly want. Without those two things, you can end up with a low price and one buyer who is delighted to pay it.

The appraiser gets a say

When a buyer is borrowing, the lender sends out an appraiser, who has to find support for the price among other sales. If the appraisal comes up short, somebody has to cover the gap or the deal has to change. A price you can defend from day one saves a lot of trouble at that stage.

Want to know where you stand?

We're glad to come by, even if a sale is still a year or two off.

Set up a walk-through

Before you list

How we'd get your home ready.

Before any money gets spent, we'd want to go through the place with you the way a stranger would. Live somewhere long enough and your eyes quit working on it. The water stain, the wobbly railing and the pile by the back door all fade away for you, and they all show up for the person seeing it for the first time.

The expensive mistake is renovating to sell. People come to us ready to tear out a kitchen, and most of the time we'd tell them to keep their money. Buyers aren't expecting a brand-new house. They want to feel that somebody took care of this one, and that costs a lot less to deliver.

Lindenhurst has canals and low ground, and buyers here ask about water. If flood insurance is part of owning your house, tell us what you pay, because a real premium is easier for a buyer to accept than a guess. Our flood zone lookup is a good place to begin, and on the water, our canal bulkhead guide covers the question buyers will raise next.

Get rid of things first

Honestly, that's most of it, and it's nearly free. Take half the books off the shelves and the extra chairs out of the dining room. Box up the collections and the framed photographs. Clear out closets until there's air between the hangers, and clean under the sinks, because people look. A storage unit for two months can be money well spent, and you're packing anyway.

Then get it truly clean

Pay for one deep cleaning if you can: windows inside and out, the grout, the oven, the baseboards, the tops of the cabinets. Odors deserve special attention. Cigarettes, animals and basement damp follow a buyer home long after the tour, and you may have stopped noticing them years ago. We haven't, and we'll tell you.

Bring in the light

Bright rooms feel bigger and happier. Raise the shades, take down heavy curtains, and swap dead bulbs for ones that match in warmth from room to room. If the walls are a bold color, a neutral coat goes a long way for not much money.

Finish the repairs you've already paid for

Say a pipe let go years ago and the plumber fixed it, but the stain is still on the ceiling below. You think of that as ancient history. A buyer thinks of it as a leak. Patch and paint it, along with the blistered sill and the spongy spot in the floor, so that fixed problems look fixed.

Where we'd put your money, in order

  • Whatever is hazardous or still happening. Water coming in, loose steps, wiring that worries anyone.
  • Whatever looks or smells neglected. Worn carpet, a musty corner, a front walk the shrubs have taken over.
  • The little stuff in bulk. Loose knobs, a running toilet, doors that stick, cracked outlet covers. A long list of tiny things reads as a house nobody watched.
  • Paint and flooring where they've worn out. These usually earn their keep.
  • Kitchens and baths, seldom. If yours is dated but clean and works, the buyer can picture what they'd do with it, and they'd rather spend their own money their own way.

The big items buyers total up

The roof, the oil tank, the furnace or boiler, the electric panel, the windows, the cesspool. People know roughly what each of these runs, and they do the arithmetic while they walk around. If you've replaced any, dig out the paperwork, because receipts are reassuring. If you haven't, that may be fine. Some of these can simply be priced, as long as nobody gets surprised three weeks in.

What a buyer is quietly asking

Could we live here? What's this going to run us once we move in? What's wrong with it that we can't see? Everything we've suggested here aims at settling those three before anybody says them out loud. Once the worry fades, people start placing their sofa in the living room, and those are the people who write good offers.

Loose ends

If you've added a dormer, a deck or a basement room over the years, find out now whether it was approved and signed off. The buyer's attorney is going to ask, and it's a far easier thing to sort out before there's a contract.

Selling it just the way it is

That's a perfectly good way to go. Maybe the money isn't there, or the time, or you've simply had enough. Houses in rough shape find buyers all the time, often people who wanted one like that all along. We'd be straightforward about the condition and price it to match, and you'd still have to disclose what you know.

Wondering where to spend?

Let one of us walk it with you before you buy so much as a can of paint.

Talk to Danielle or Kim

Listing it

Getting it in front of the right buyers.

Most buyers will first meet your home on a phone, half watching television. A picture has about a second to make them stop, and that's why photographs come after the house is ready, never before.

The night before the pictures

  • Clear off the counters, kitchen and baths both, right down to the soap dish.
  • Make the beds, and leave the dressers and night tables bare.
  • Take the magnets off the fridge, hide the cords, and tuck the pet dishes and garbage pails out of sight.
  • Raise the shades, turn on every lamp, and move the cars out of the driveway.
  • Cut the grass, edge the walk and coil up the hose. The front of the house is usually the opening shot.

It takes a couple of hours and it shows up in every shot. Nobody is hiding anything here. The point is to catch the house at its nicest.

Going on the market once

A listing that appears before it's finished, disappears and comes back has told everybody something is off. A house is only new to the market one time. So the pictures, the wording and the paperwork should all be done before it goes live, and the price should be settled by then too.

Showings

It's a pain, and we know it. Keep a bin in the car for last-minute clutter, take the dog out, and leave the lights on. People linger and talk more freely when no owner is hovering nearby, and you want them talking. We'll work around your schedule as much as we can, and we'll keep you informed about how it's going.

When offers come in

The highest offer isn't always the one you want.

A big offer that collapses a month and a half later, with the moving truck already reserved, is worth less than a smaller one that closes. Kim's 25 years in mortgage and underwriting and Danielle's years in title closings are why we care so much about what stands behind an offer and what has to be clear before the closing. Every offer gets weighed on all of its terms, we'll tell you which we'd take and why, and you make the decision.

What's in an offer besides the price

  • The money. Is it cash or a loan? A pre-approval letter is written early, and it doesn't mean the loan is done.
  • How much is going down. A buyer with more cash has more room if an appraisal lands short.
  • The inspection. Which things will they inspect, and what do they expect from you if something turns up?
  • The closing date. Will that date fit your next move?
  • Strings attached. A buyer who has to sell a home first has made your sale depend on someone else's.

Several offers at once

Good. Slow down anyway. We can set a deadline, invite everyone to put their strongest terms forward, and then compare the whole picture. Don't let the excitement of a big number blind you to a shaky loan. Sometimes the buyer offering $10,000 less is the one who gets you to the closing table.

The inspection report

It's going to be long, and on an older house it's going to be very long. Take a breath. Most of what's in there is a description of an older house. We'd sort it into real problems, items any new owner would just handle, and things that are simply an inspector covering all the bases. Then we'd figure out what's worth giving on and where to hold, keeping in mind that the next buyer's inspector would find the same things.

What it will cost you

CommissionNegotiable. We put it in writing before your house is listed.
Attorney's feeNew York sellers hire a lawyer for the contract and the closing. Ask for the fee up front.
New York transfer taxThe state charges $2 per $500, and by custom the seller pays it. On a $650,000 sale, that comes to $2,600.
Your existing mortgageWhatever is still owed gets paid from the proceeds at closing.
AdjustmentsProperty taxes and similar bills are prorated to the closing day by the attorneys.

Ask us to estimate your net before you decide anything. Selling is a lot easier when you already know the number that matters.

Paperwork and keys

From accepted offer to closing.

An accepted offer in New York isn't a sale yet, because nobody is committed until contracts are signed by both sides. Selling a home in Lindenhurst tends to run in this order:

  1. Lawyers step in. Your lawyer drafts the contract and looks after you from here on, so have someone in mind before you list.
  2. The inspection. Buyers typically inspect before signing, so what's found gets dealt with in the contract.
  3. Your disclosure statement. New York requires you to complete a property condition disclosure form and deliver it to the buyer before they sign. Answer from what you know.
  4. Signed contracts and the deposit. The deposit goes into escrow, and the deal is now real for both of you.
  5. The loan gets underwritten. An appraiser is sent out and the lender works up a written commitment. This stretch tends to take the longest.
  6. Title work. A title company goes through the history of the property for anything standing in the way of a clean transfer.
  7. Walk-through and closing. One more look at the house for the buyer, then signatures, your mortgage paid off from the proceeds, and the keys change hands.

Through all of this we try to keep things moving and keep you posted, so that nothing about your own sale comes as news to you.

The harder kinds of sale

When it isn't simple.

Some people call because they're moving somewhere warmer. Others call because something happened, and now there's a house to deal with. Here's how we'd approach the harder ones.

A house you've inherited

Don't rush this. The first thing to find out, from the estate's attorney, is who can legally sign for the estate, because very little can move until that's settled. In the meantime keep the house insured and heated and have the mail forwarded. The closets can wait. An estate tends to bring extra paperwork to the closing table, and it helps to start on it early.

Moving to less house

Decades in one place don't get packed in a weekend. Begin with a room nobody uses, and choose the things that are moving with you first. The rest gets easier after that. Settle your next address before we choose a closing date. Scrambling is what makes these moves hard.

Selling one house while buying another

It depends on your numbers. Can you qualify for the new home without selling this one? Can your contract give you a little time? Talk with a lender before either side gets going. We can work on the sale and the purchase together, with the aim of not leaving you between homes.

If you've moved away

There's no need to fly back for this. We can let people in and out, and your lawyer can explain signing from a distance.

If you're having second thoughts

Call anyway. It's a perfectly fine reason to talk. Leaving a home means something, and sometimes the answer is to stay put and fix the roof. We'd tell you so.

From people who sold with us

What our sellers say.

"Danielle and Kim helped us sell our home fast and made everything feel smooth and stress-free."

Victoria Medina, April 2026

"They were also very flexible, working around our schedule and making sure we felt confident in every decision we made."

Victoria Medina, April 2026

"I've used Danielle in the past for the sale of my home, and more recently on the purchase of my new one."

Michael Klein, October 2024

"Her attention to detail was great."

Michael Klein, October 2024

Recent work

Homes we've sold.

A few of the homes we sold as the listing agents, out of the 30 on our sold page.

  • Photograph of 4 Balsam Lane

    4 Balsam Lane, Commack

    Sold for $810,000

    Sold September 2026

  • Photograph of 5 Dogwood Court

    5 Dogwood Court, Selden

    Sold for $250,000

    Sold April 2026

  • Photograph of 138 Brattle Circle

    138 Brattle Circle, Melville

    Sold for $646,250

    Sold April 2026

  • Photograph of 111 Cedar Oaks Avenue

    111 Cedar Oaks Avenue, Farmingville

    Sold for $630,000

    Sold January 2026

  • Photograph of 171 Hale Avenue

    171 Hale Avenue, Brooklyn

    Sold for $840,000

    Sold October 2025

  • Photograph of 2448 Amherst Street

    2448 Amherst Street, East Meadow

    Sold for $693,000

    Sold September 2025

Asked and answered

What Lindenhurst sellers ask us.

Who should sell my home in Lindenhurst?

We'd be glad to talk it over with you. We're The SisterListers at Signature Premier Properties: Danielle Sandella and Kim Fontanez, each a Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, with 30 listing-side sales between us. Kim has lived in Lindenhurst for 40 years, and one of us walks every house we list. Kim's Mobile is (631) 404-5882.

How soon could I sell my home in Lindenhurst?

The panel above shows how quickly Lindenhurst homes are finding buyers right now. Once you've accepted an offer, allow six to ten weeks or so to reach the closing, most of it driven by the buyer's lender.

Would spring be a better time?

More buyers come out in spring, and so do more competing houses. Homes can take longer to find a buyer in winter, and that alone doesn't make it a bad time to sell. If the house is ready and your plans call for moving, we wouldn't hold off just for the flowers. If it needs a few months of work anyway, spring could suit you well.

What is my Lindenhurst home worth?

We can't tell you honestly until one of us has walked through it. Online figures and the median on this page describe the town. What a buyer pays for your house comes down to its layout, its taxes, its roof and its block, so we'd go through the closed sales near you together, and you'd see how we got to the number.

What's worth fixing before I list?

Start by naming a budget, zero included. If there's nothing to spend, clearing out, cleaning and an honest price will do most of the work. With a few thousand dollars, we'd point you at the repairs a buyer will notice. Above that, paint and flooring come next. Don't spend anything just because you feel you're supposed to.

Can I sell it as it stands?

Yes. The price has to reflect the condition, and whatever you know about it still has to be disclosed. Plenty of buyers come looking for a house they can make their own.

Should I stay home for showings?

Better to step out. Buyers take their time and speak freely with nobody home to overhear. We'll work around your schedule as much as we can.

Do I need to be living there to sell it?

No. We can let people in and out, and your lawyer can explain signing from a distance.

Should I take the first offer?

Don't grab it, and don't dismiss it. Early offers often come from people who have been watching the market for months. Judge it against what's selling and on whether that buyer can really get to the closing.

What must I tell a buyer about the house's problems?

Be truthful. The New York disclosure form covers what you know about the place, and your lawyer can walk you through each question. Something disclosed up front becomes a matter of price and terms. Something a buyer discovers alone makes them doubt everything else.

How does the commission work?

It's open to negotiation, and we write it down before your house is listed. We'll go through it together and tell you what you get for it.

What does a first conversation cost?

Nothing. Call even if you're a year away. Kim's Mobile is (631) 404-5882, Danielle's Mobile is (631) 513-9821, and our Office is (631) 360-2800.

When it suits you

Let's talk about your Lindenhurst home.

Lindenhurst has been Kim's home for 40 years, and we'd be glad to come see yours. You don't need a date or a plan to call us. Tell us about the house and what's on your mind, and we'll give you our honest read. The SisterListers at Signature Premier Properties, in Smithtown at 7 West Main Street. Office: (631) 360-2800.

Danielle Sandella and Kim Fontanez Talk to Danielle and Kim